Image Image
   
  Home Forum Calendar Top Tips Contact Societies and Clubs Suppliers Product Reviews Kit Bashing Hobby Web Site My Railway  
Image Image

The EJ&KLR: Austrian narrow gauge in Cheshire

Change Page: < 12345678910.. > >> | Showing page 2 of 18, messages 21 to 40 of 342
Author Message
jameshilton

  • Total Posts : 1339
  • Reward points : 2175
  • Joined: 22/Nov/2010
  • Location: Cheshire
  • Status: online
Re:The EJ&KLR project 27/02/11 06:37 PM (permalink)
Thanks chaps, I may try some R3 points... do they do a manual version?

 
#21
    yb281

    • Total Posts : 8190
    • Reward points : 3482
    • Joined: 24/Oct/2009
    • Location: Worcestershire
    • Status: offline
    Re:The EJ&KLR project 27/02/11 06:44 PM (permalink)
    [This post was marked as helpful]
    James, I think you will find this thread very useful.
     
    http://www.gscalecentral.co.uk/f/m63991.aspx
     
    The Piko points are manual. I have one and have no problem in recommending it very highly.
    Mel, CMO and chief sausage knotter, the Wetton Gooey Light Railway.
    The advantages of simplifying origami are two-fold


    https://www.facebook.com/pages/Wetton-Gooey-Light-Railway/246392918762922
     
    #22
      stockers

      • Total Posts : 4861
      • Reward points : 3363
      • Status: offline
      Re:The EJ&KLR project 27/02/11 06:57 PM (permalink)
      Or try E-bay
      Alan.

      The Oxney Island Line in the heart of Kent.

      http://www.pendleburymodels.com/
       
      #23
        jameshilton

        • Total Posts : 1339
        • Reward points : 2175
        • Joined: 22/Nov/2010
        • Location: Cheshire
        • Status: online
        Re:The EJ&KLR project 27/02/11 07:21 PM (permalink)
        Thanks guys - I've done a plan with the R3 points and it looks SO much better, so will price that up... as for the rest of the track plan, I actually like the tightening of the apex when using R1s, and I don't think I can get the plan in without using them. Anyone experience of tightening a curve in this manner (my curves go R3, R2, R1) and using bogie stock? I do plan on getting a pair of OBB green bogie coaches at some point so want to make sure they'll be ok.

         
        #24
          yb281

          • Total Posts : 8190
          • Reward points : 3482
          • Joined: 24/Oct/2009
          • Location: Worcestershire
          • Status: offline
          Re:The EJ&KLR project 27/02/11 07:25 PM (permalink)
          [This post was marked as helpful]
          jameshilton


          Thanks guys - I've done a plan with the R3 points and it looks SO much better, so will price that up... as for the rest of the track plan, I actually like the tightening of the apex when using R1s, and I don't think I can get the plan in without using them. Anyone experience of tightening a curve in this manner (my curves go R3, R2, R1) and using bogie stock? I do plan on getting a pair of OBB green bogie coaches at some point so want to make sure they'll be ok.

          Transitional curves are a good idea. An alternative would be to have a look at flexible track to make an even smoother transition?
           
          Any LGB bogie coaches (within reason) will go round R1 without probs - as to what they will look like? That's a matter of taste.
          Mel, CMO and chief sausage knotter, the Wetton Gooey Light Railway.
          The advantages of simplifying origami are two-fold


          https://www.facebook.com/pages/Wetton-Gooey-Light-Railway/246392918762922
           
          #25
            stockers

            • Total Posts : 4861
            • Reward points : 3363
            • Status: offline
            Re:The EJ&KLR project 27/02/11 07:50 PM (permalink)
            jameshilton


            my curves go R3, R2, R1


            Sure it wil look good and probably run better than going straight into R1s. Nice plan.
            Alan.

            The Oxney Island Line in the heart of Kent.

            http://www.pendleburymodels.com/
             
            #26
              shropshire lad

              • Total Posts : 804
              • Reward points : 3205
              • Joined: 25/Jan/2010
              • Location: Sunny Shropshire
              • Status: online
              Re:The EJ&KLR project 27/02/11 09:14 PM (permalink)
              [This post was marked as helpful]
              Looks good James, like me I'm guessing you're hoping the weather will pick up.
              I've got some bogie coaches which run on R1 curves, they overhang but I can live with it because I haven't the space to use bigger ones, it's a personal preference thing.
              Colin
              Lenz DCC with wireless Navigators running a Rule 8 railway
               
              #27
                JRinTawa

                • Total Posts : 1420
                • Reward points : 2699
                • Joined: 25/Oct/2009
                • Location: Tawa, New Zealand
                • Status: offline
                Re:The EJ&KLR project 27/02/11 09:29 PM (permalink)
                [This post was marked as helpful]
                Hi James.  As others have said keep radius as big as you can but either way transitions are an excellent plan.  On our railway we're lucky to have the tightest radius of 4'/1250mm (I think that's LGB R3?).  We used Aristo-craft curves and used a length or tow of 8' radius, stepping down through 5' radius to 4' radius, a poor mans transition curve!  Looks much more pleasing to the eye and doesn't really increase the real estate a curve takes up, i.e. the transition happening partly on what would have been straight track.
                John
                Principal Operator of the H&M Garden Railway & organiser Wellington Garden Railway Group
                I don't take myself seriously, so I apologize if you do.
                 
                #28
                  jameshilton

                  • Total Posts : 1339
                  • Reward points : 2175
                  • Joined: 22/Nov/2010
                  • Location: Cheshire
                  • Status: online
                  Re:The EJ&KLR project 27/02/11 10:41 PM (permalink)
                  Colin - yes definitely, got some clearance done but I need a full weekend at it to fully prepare the area, before I can mark out the route and begin earthworks!

                  John - it was looking at your layout that convinced me to use flowing curves and transitions where possible - although I've had to go right down to R1s in a couple of places. 
                   
                  Alan - thank you, yes even on the earlier plans transition curves looked so much more realistic

                   
                  #29
                    Tony

                    • Total Posts : 1209
                    • Reward points : 3095
                    • Joined: 28/Feb/2010
                    • Location: East coast Essex
                    • Status: offline
                    Re:The EJ&KLR project 27/02/11 11:00 PM (permalink)
                    James love the plan i like the wiggly curves it give far more intrest than straight lines. but if your like me once its in operation you will see things you wish you had done differently. as i have found one little tweek allows 10 times the operational fun. one thing to think about that i would ad (but it would need isolating at both ends) would be to ad two more points and a short straight between the curves of the two loops on the left hand side that way you can have the loco change direction if you dont understand what i mean il draw a plan
                    Tony
                    Life's to short--------- And so is my back garden 

                     My Facebook Page  
                     http://www.facebook.com/pages/St-Margrets-and-Dimchurch-Railway/188410544603017  
                     
                    My YouTube Page
                    http://www.youtube.com/user/valeriejane61
                                                
                     
                    #30
                      jameshilton

                      • Total Posts : 1339
                      • Reward points : 2175
                      • Joined: 22/Nov/2010
                      • Location: Cheshire
                      • Status: online
                      Re:The EJ&KLR project 27/02/11 11:04 PM (permalink)
                      Thanks Tony, I understand what you mean - I'm not sure of the visuals though, and the gradient involved, as the climb down from the bridge continues around the curve. I'll be ordering the track in the next few weeks so will have a think about it.
                       
                      Does anyone else look at the plan and think, with their experience/hindsight they'd add/remove/change anything?
                       

                       
                      #31
                        mbiff

                        • Total Posts : 915
                        • Reward points : 3483
                        • Status: offline
                        Re:The EJ&KLR project 27/02/11 11:06 PM (permalink)
                        Real Big Smile super duper matey - likes the computer imaging
                         
                        #32
                          jameshilton

                          • Total Posts : 1339
                          • Reward points : 2175
                          • Joined: 22/Nov/2010
                          • Location: Cheshire
                          • Status: online
                          Re:The EJ&KLR project 28/02/11 09:52 PM (permalink)
                          I've tweaked the plan to use R3 points, and lengthened the loop slightly. Unfortunately this is messing with the gradients!
                           
                          I want some candid advice really, for this to work I now need to drop at 2.5% from the 'south' end of the station (assuming up is north on the plan) to the bridge site where the line goes under - this loses 6.15cm.
                          From the north end of the station loop the line climbs at 2.5% to 21cm above the lower track at the bridge point.
                          The loop is assumed level, at 6.15cm above the lowest point.
                          The other side of the bridge drops at 2.2% to the low point.
                           
                          This means the station area and the 1.2m long bridge are the only level sections of line, and that the majority of the loop is climbing or falling at about 2.5%.
                           
                          What effect will this have on locomotive performance? I'll be running LGB electrically, track powered locomotives initially on analog (later digital). Typical size will be U-tank, possibly a Rugen 0-8-0 or Frank S in future. Trains 3 short coaches or 2 bogie coaches long (most of the time!). Will I get surging on the down grades, will I wear out motors on the climbs? Will I find the rain/wet weather makes the line un-usable? Should I go with something on the level if this is the space I have to play with?
                           
                          Please - honest experience welcomed!
                           

                          Attached Image(s)

                           
                          #33
                            mike

                            • Total Posts : 10453
                            • Reward points : 3467
                            • Joined: 24/Oct/2009
                            • Status: online
                            Re:The EJ&KLR project 28/02/11 10:01 PM (permalink)
                            [This post was marked as helpful]
                            any gradent, is going to afect how locos perform, its a decacte balansceing act..
                            on the bright side, if you find a locos struggling, BUY A BIGGER ONEReal Big Smile
                            testing.. it HAS A PURPOSE


                            Attached Image(s)
                            RULE *8*

                            The most important rule...........
                            ITS MY RAILWAY, I WILL RUN WHAT I WANT, WHEN I WANT, HOW I WANT, AND IF YOU DONT LIKE IT..........
                            BUGGER OFF!
                             
                            #34
                              jameshilton

                              • Total Posts : 1339
                              • Reward points : 2175
                              • Joined: 22/Nov/2010
                              • Location: Cheshire
                              • Status: online
                              Re:The EJ&KLR project 28/02/11 10:07 PM (permalink)
                              Thanks Mike - I want to get the benefit of years of experience before purchasing any further track - I guess I'm most interested in people who do run a gradient, what are the downsides, does wet track make a difference, and things like that... 

                              Unfortunately I'm building the railway at my parents home - it was to be a joint project with my father before he passed away at the beginning of the year. I guess anyone who's experienced that will appreciate that it's tough - I want to do the right thing and I've not got much experience of grades on models, as my 4mm stuff has always been on the level
                               
                              Whatever advice people can share is really appreciated!  

                               
                              #35
                                Stainzmeister

                                • Total Posts : 1094
                                • Reward points : 2777
                                • Joined: 24/Oct/2009
                                • Location: North Wales
                                • Status: offline
                                Re:The EJ&KLR project 28/02/11 10:14 PM (permalink)
                                [This post was marked as helpful]
                                James, you will have no problem with the stock and track plan you propose which includes the gradients. My line has very similar gradients to your proposals - mine include R1 half circles so I can have the switchbacks I need to get up the bank in a relatively short space. This trackplan is not bang up to date, but is essentially what I have out in the garden.
                                 
                                My line runs Rugens, Frank S, U Class and every other Austrian and several German LGB locos.
                                If you only run 3 wagon/coach trains they will be fine.
                                 

                                <message edited by Stainzmeister on 28/02/11 10:18 PM>
                                Austrian narrow gauge in North Wales

                                http://linzgstadtbahn.webs.com/index.htm
                                 
                                #36
                                  mike

                                  • Total Posts : 10453
                                  • Reward points : 3467
                                  • Joined: 24/Oct/2009
                                  • Status: online
                                  Re:The EJ&KLR project 28/02/11 10:21 PM (permalink)
                                  jameshilton


                                  Thanks Mike - I want to get the benefit of years of experience before purchasing any further track - I guess I'm most interested in people who do run a gradient, what are the downsides, does wet track make a difference, and things like that... 

                                  Unfortunately I'm building the railway at my parents home - it was to be a joint project with my father before he passed away at the beginning of the year. I guess anyone who's experienced that will appreciate that it's tough - I want to do the right thing and I've not got much experience of grades on models, as my 4mm stuff has always been on the level

                                  Whatever advice people can share is really appreciated!  


                                  ahh. experiansce.. yes..
                                  if its wet. stuff that normally gose up, will struggle..
                                  only run your track cleaner downhill...(think about it)
                                  steamlocos, will not like hills..
                                  bewear the drawstring effect when hauling long trains
                                  its best to mess about, with a peacse off wood, testing what you think is a asceptable gradent.. ,i setteled for a drop off 10 inches over 15ft..
                                  its not advisable to put point on a grade, always try to get them level,
                                  what im trying to get across, is.. go get a peasce off wood, and try it out .. its the only way ,really,


                                   
                                   
                                  is that okReal Big Smile
                                  Attached Image(s)
                                  RULE *8*

                                  The most important rule...........
                                  ITS MY RAILWAY, I WILL RUN WHAT I WANT, WHEN I WANT, HOW I WANT, AND IF YOU DONT LIKE IT..........
                                  BUGGER OFF!
                                   
                                  #37
                                    jameshilton

                                    • Total Posts : 1339
                                    • Reward points : 2175
                                    • Joined: 22/Nov/2010
                                    • Location: Cheshire
                                    • Status: online
                                    Re:The EJ&KLR project 28/02/11 10:24 PM (permalink)
                                    Yes Mike - thank you - there will be 'testing' but I'm sat at my house doing the maths, and planning the layout - 50 miles away from the stock and track!
                                     
                                    Paul - that has given me some confidence, thank you!
                                    I'll try and re-jig the location of the bridge I think to give me slightly more length of run to get the height gain.

                                     
                                    #38
                                      Stainzmeister

                                      • Total Posts : 1094
                                      • Reward points : 2777
                                      • Joined: 24/Oct/2009
                                      • Location: North Wales
                                      • Status: offline
                                      Re:The EJ&KLR project 28/02/11 10:29 PM (permalink)
                                      [This post was marked as helpful]
                                      A couple of places on my line are 3.5 - 4 % and some of my locos are now 6 years old with absolutely no wear on the D gearboxes.
                                      Some of my Stainz locos are 2.25 kilos each (The pre Marklin Stainz were originally 1.8 kilos).
                                      My Saxon Meyer and The 2095 s all have added lead weight - no detriment to the gearboxes and with a dozen exceptions most of my locos get run often.
                                       

                                      Austrian narrow gauge in North Wales

                                      http://linzgstadtbahn.webs.com/index.htm
                                       
                                      #39
                                        Tony

                                        • Total Posts : 1209
                                        • Reward points : 3095
                                        • Joined: 28/Feb/2010
                                        • Location: East coast Essex
                                        • Status: offline
                                        Re:The EJ&KLR project 28/02/11 10:38 PM (permalink)
                                        [This post was marked as helpful]
                                        James believe me with the locos your using and only two coaches you will hardly notice the difference in speed, take a look at my gradients there is a fine line between some small locos making it up a long hill with 5 or 6 box cars and one more and it spins the wheels, i dont know the maths of my hills but i have a figure eight section ive just put in (not on my videos) where the track rise's 9" in the space of a 3\4 circle using rad 3 curves and everything copes with it so far with no problem pulling up to 10 double bogie wagons where the last wagon is under the bridge and the loco is on top
                                        one other thing i dont thing your hills are long enough that even with a really long train all the train would be going up hill at the same time. in other words when the loco is going up hill with a long train only a few wagons are on the hill the others would be on the flat or going down the previous hill.
                                         
                                        I know what i mean
                                        Tony
                                        Life's to short--------- And so is my back garden 

                                         My Facebook Page  
                                         http://www.facebook.com/pages/St-Margrets-and-Dimchurch-Railway/188410544603017  
                                         
                                        My YouTube Page
                                        http://www.youtube.com/user/valeriejane61
                                                                    
                                         
                                        #40
                                          Online Bookmarks Sharing: Share/Bookmark
                                          Change Page: < 12345678910.. > >> | Showing page 2 of 18, messages 21 to 40 of 342

                                          Jump to:

                                          Current active users

                                          There are 0 members and 2 guests.

                                          Icon Legend and Permission

                                          • New Messages
                                          • No New Messages
                                          • Hot Topic w/ New Messages
                                          • Hot Topic w/o New Messages
                                          • Locked w/ New Messages
                                          • Locked w/o New Messages
                                          • Read Message
                                          • Post New Thread
                                          • Reply to message
                                          • Post New Poll
                                          • Submit Vote
                                          • Post reward post
                                          • Delete my own posts
                                          • Delete my own threads
                                          • Rate post

                                          2000-2012 ASPPlayground.NET Forum Version 3.8

                                          Site Built By internet Solutions Services Limited ISSL Built In Rossendale